A Heretical View of File Sharing
What if the industry is wrong, and file sharing is not hurting record sales? A new report suggests just that. [New York Times: Technology]

The music industry says it repeatedly, with passion and conviction: downloading hurts sales.

That statement is at the heart of the war on file sharing, both of music and movies, and underpins lawsuits against thousands of music fans, as well as legislation approved last week by a House Judiciary subcommittee that would create federal penalties for using what is known as peer-to-peer technology to download copyrighted works. It is also part of the reason that the Justice Department introduced an intellectual-property task force last week that plans to step up criminal prosecutions of copyright infringers.


But what if the industry is wrong, and file sharing is not hurting record sales?

It might seem counterintuitive, but that is the conclusion reached by two economists who released a draft last week of the first study that makes a rigorous economic comparison of directly observed activity on file-sharing networks and music buying.

"Downloads have an effect on sales which is statistically indistinguishable from zero, despite rather precise estimates," write its authors, Felix Oberholzer-Gee of the Harvard Business School and Koleman S. Strumpf of the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill.

The industry has reacted with the kind of flustered consternation that the White House might display if Richard A. Clarke showed up at a Rose Garden tea party. Last week, the Recording Industry Association of America sent out three versions of a six-page response to the study.


In other words, the RIAA is a collection of asswipes and whores. If the contemporary music industry (for the most part) didn't suck so bad, people might buy things. And who wants to pay more for 17 lame songs than for a director's edition of a classic Hollywood movie on DVD? Something needs to change, imho.


Now playing: Country Blue, from the album The Jimi Hendrix Experience Box Set (Disc 4) by Jimi Hendrix (released 2000)